| FUDforum for a big board - some thoughts... [message #23514] |
Sat, 19 March 2005 01:03  |
 |
s03nk3
Messages: 13
Registered: July 2002
Karma:
|
Junior Member |
|
|
I'm currently doing a review of FUDforum's sources to check out if it is usable for a larger forum (100k registered users, 2M posts, 1k users online/15min session).
The first drawback for us is the fact that FUDforum places its messages in the filesystem rather inside the database.
I know that this issue has been discussed many times before, but it is considered a major drawback as things like database replication/clustering won't work (no need currently, but we're growing).
The FUDforum developers often pointed out that this can be changed easily, but a quick search through the CVS sources showed 21 files (30 when also counting the conversion scripts) which make use of the files.
The second problem is the code itself.
Passages like if ($obj->avatar_loc && $a & 8388608 && $b & 8192 && $o1 & 28 && !($c & 2)) { show it: The code is partially hard to understand and to manage.
The third issue is the lack of a thorough code review/security audit due to a small base of installed forums.
The fourth point is the absense of experiences of FUDforum's usability on a big forum. No one really knows how it actually performs when hundreds of users or even a thousand users are hitting the server.
Some simple dry tests (analyzing SQL queries, tracing memory usage, ...) showed that it FUDforum should be able to compete with vBulletin and phpBB2.xCVS, but real world examples are missing.
The result is that I'm really torn: On the one hand I really like FUDforum and admire the developer's work, on the other hand I'm not sure if FUDforum could be the right choice for my needs.
Maybe somebody can enlighten one or more poits...
P.S.: Thx, Ilia - you're doing a great work.
|
|
|
|
Calendar
Search
Help
Members
Register
Login
Home
]